Introduction
- The Railways (Amendment) Bill, 2024, recently passed in the Lok Sabha, represents a major shift in the governance of Indian Railways.
- This reform seeks to modernize the legal framework governing the railways by repealing the Indian Railway Board Act, 1905, and incorporating its provisions into the Railways Act, 1989.
- The Bill not only simplifies the legal structure but also addresses critical challenges such as financial sustainability, governance, and the modernization of railway infrastructure.
Key Objectives of the Railways (Amendment) Bill, 2024
- The Railways (Amendment) Bill, 2024 is designed to achieve the following goals:
- Providing Statutory Backing to the Railway Board: The Railway Board, which has functioned without legislative backing, will now be officially recognized under the Railways Act, 1989, providing it with statutory authority and ensuring a solid legal framework.
- Simplifying the Legal Framework: The Bill integrates the provisions of the Indian Railway Board Act, 1905, into the Railways Act, 1989. This consolidation removes redundant legislation and streamlines the legal framework governing Indian Railways.
Read also: Universal Health Coverage in India | UPSC
Development of Indian Railways
- 1890: The Indian Railways Act, 1890, was introduced to regulate railway operations, establishing the first formal legal framework for the railways.
- 1905: The Indian Railway Board Act, 1905, was passed, creating the Railway Board and granting it specific powers and responsibilities under the Indian Railways Act, 1890. This also marked the separation of the railway organization from the Public Works Department.
- 1989: The Indian Railways Act, 1890, was replaced by the Railways Act, 1989, which modernized railway operations. However, the provisions of the Indian Railway Board Act, 1905, remained in effect, with the Chairman and members of the Railway Board continuing to be appointed under its terms.
Key Features of the Bill
- Constitution of the Railway Board: The Bill authorizes the Central Government to decide on the number of Railway Board members, their qualifications, and their terms of service. It also specifies how the Chairman and members will be appointed, ensuring a merit-based process for leadership selection.
- Infrastructure Upgrades: The Bill focuses on infrastructure modernization, including the development of superfast trains and the extension of vital routes like the Arunachal Express. These upgrades are backed by substantial investments to enhance connectivity and improve the quality of rail services.
- Establishment of an Independent Regulator: A key feature of the Bill is the creation of an independent regulatory authority. This regulator will oversee key areas such as tariff regulation, safety standards, and private sector participation, ensuring fair practices and a competitive environment for railway operations.
- Decentralization and Greater Autonomy: The Bill proposes to decentralize power by granting greater autonomy to Railway Zones. This will help streamline operations, accelerate decision-making, and improve the efficiency of service delivery.
Why Was the Amendment Necessary?
- Under-investment in Infrastructure: The lack of private sector involvement and insufficient revenue generation have hindered the expansion of the railway network and its modernization.
- Network Congestion: A congested network reduces the competitiveness of freight transport, which further affects revenue generation for Indian Railways.
- An example of this problem is seen in the Delhi-Howrah route, one of the busiest in India, where the line is congested with more than 40 trains per day running on it.
- Rising Operating Costs: A substantial portion of Indian Railways’ budget is allocated to salaries and pensions, which accounts for about 60% of the total operational costs. According to a report by the Indian Railways Finance Corporation (IRFC), wages, pensions, and other employee benefits are one of the largest financial burdens on Indian Railways.
- Losses in Passenger Services: The cross-subsidization of passenger services by freight revenues has strained finances, with underpriced tickets contributing to financial losses.
- For example, low-cost fares for passengers traveling in sleeper and second-class compartments contribute to losses. According to the 2016-17 Annual Report of Indian Railways, the passenger segment registered a loss of around ₹30,000 crore, with freight services being cross-subsidized to cover these losses.
- Legal Complexity: The coexistence of the Indian Railway Board Act, 1905, and the Railways Act, 1989, created confusion and inefficiency in the governance of Indian Railways.
Alignment with Expert Recommendations
- The Sreedharan Committee (2014): This committee recommended increasing autonomy for railway zones and restructuring the Railway Board for better governance.
- The Bibek Debroy Committee (2015): The committee called for the establishment of an independent regulator and liberalization of the railway sector to allow private operators to participate, thereby increasing competition and improving service quality.
The Importance of the Bill
- The Railways (Amendment) Bill, 2024 holds significant importance in several areas:
- Supporting National Development Goals: By modernizing the railway system, the Bill aligns with India’s larger economic and infrastructure development goals, facilitating better connectivity, reducing logistics costs, and increasing the competitiveness of Indian freight transport.
- The Bill supports the development of superfast trains and critical routes such as the Dedicated Freight Corridors (DFC. According to the Ministry of Railways, the introduction of DFCs can reduce logistics costs by up to 3-4%, benefiting industries and helping boost India’s GDP growth.
- Increased Operational Efficiency: With greater autonomy granted to Railway Zones, the Bill ensures that decisions can be made more swiftly and efficiently, reducing bureaucratic delays and enhancing service delivery across the country.
- Encouraging Private Sector Participation: The creation of an independent regulatory body ensures a fair and transparent environment for private sector involvement, attracting investment and improving the quality of railway services.
- The Vande Bharat Express project, where private firms contributed to the production of coaches, is an example of how private sector involvement can enhance the quality of services and infrastructure.
- Legal Simplification: By merging the provisions of the Indian Railway Board Act, 1905, into the 1989 Act, the Bill streamlines railway governance and reduces redundancies, making the legal framework clearer and more effective.
- A unified legal framework will speed up approval processes for vital infrastructure projects such as the Mumbai-Ahmedabad High-Speed Rail Corridor, which can now proceed with fewer bureaucratic hurdles.
- Improved Governance and Accountability: The Bill empowers the Central Government to define qualifications, terms, and conditions for Railway Board appointments, ensuring that these are based on merit and not political considerations, which strengthens governance and accountability.
Addressing Potential Concerns
- Despite the many benefits, the Bill faces several concerns, including:
- Impact on Autonomy: Critics argue that greater government control over the Railway Board appointments could lead to the politicization of key decisions, reducing the autonomy and operational efficiency of Indian Railways.
- Passenger Welfare: The discontinuation of fare concessions for senior citizens and economically weaker sections during the pandemic has raised concerns. MPs have called for restoring these concessions to maintain the railways’ social responsibility.
- Uncertainty Regarding the Regulator: While the Bill proposes an independent regulator, details on its structure, responsibilities, and operational framework remain unclear, raising doubts about its effectiveness in regulating the sector.
- Privatization Concerns: Opposition parties, particularly Congress, fear that the Bill may lay the groundwork for privatization of Indian Railways, which could undermine accessibility for low-income groups and lead to fare hikes.
- Regional Inequalities: Some critics argue that prioritizing certain regions for infrastructure upgrades could exacerbate regional inequalities, leaving other areas underdeveloped and further deepening the urban-rural divide.
See more: Understanding Jet Streams: Formation, Types, Distribution, and Effects | UPSC
Way Forward
- For the Railways (Amendment) Bill, 2024 to succeed, it is crucial to address several key challenges:
- Clarifying the Regulator’s Role: The independent regulator must have clearly defined powers, structure, and operational guidelines to ensure its effectiveness in overseeing the railway sector and maintaining fairness in pricing and safety standards.
- Decentralization with Oversight: While granting greater autonomy to Railway Zones, it is essential to implement oversight mechanisms to ensure that decentralized decisions align with national priorities and best practices.
- Safeguarding Public Interests: Any move toward private sector participation must prioritize affordability and accessibility, ensuring that the public is not sidelined for profit maximization. Adequate safeguards should be implemented to prevent exploitation.
- Transparent Appointment Process: Merit-based appointments for Railway Board members should be ensured, and the appointment process must remain transparent and free from political influence, guaranteeing better governance.
- Ensuring Balanced Regional Development: Infrastructure projects must be planned in a way that promotes equitable regional development and prevents disparities. Ensuring that all regions benefit from railway improvements will foster national integration and inclusive growth.
- Financial Sustainability: The Bill should consider innovative measures to cut operating costs, improve revenue generation, and encourage private investment, ensuring that the railway system remains financially viable without compromising public welfare.
